AR-15 uppers without forward assists are becoming increasingly popular among experienced shooters and builders. This article explores the reasons behind this trend, the implications of this design choice, and the considerations for those contemplating building or purchasing an AR-15 upper without this feature. We'll cover the functionality, potential benefits and drawbacks, and ultimately help you decide if this design is right for you.
Understanding the Forward Assist's Role
Before diving into the specifics of AR uppers without forward assists, let's review the purpose of the forward assist itself. The forward assist is a small lever located on the right side of the upper receiver. Its primary function is to help chamber a round that is slightly out of battery. This can happen due to various factors, including:
- Improper loading: A round might not be fully seated into the chamber.
- Dirty or damaged parts: Buildup of debris or damage to the bolt carrier group (BCG) can impede proper chambering.
- Ammunition issues: Variations in ammunition can sometimes cause feeding problems.
The forward assist provides a mechanical advantage to push the bolt fully forward, ensuring the round is properly chambered. It's considered a safety feature, as a round not fully chambered can lead to malfunctions or even dangerous misfires.
Why Choose an AR Upper Without Forward Assist?
While the forward assist is a standard feature on most AR-15s, many shooters opt for uppers without it. The reasons are varied:
1. Enhanced Reliability: The Case for Omission
Ironically, some argue that the absence of a forward assist enhances reliability. This perspective suggests that if your AR-15 requires frequent use of the forward assist, it points towards underlying issues within the rifle's system—issues that are best addressed by fixing the root problem rather than relying on the forward assist as a crutch. Properly functioning BCG, springs, and ammunition greatly reduce the need for a forward assist in the first place.
2. Streamlined Design and Reduced Weight
Removing the forward assist and its associated components reduces the overall weight of the upper receiver. This can be a significant advantage for those prioritizing lightweight builds, especially for tactical applications or extended periods of carrying the weapon. Every ounce counts, and removing unnecessary features contributes to a lighter overall rifle weight.
3. Aesthetical Preference
For some shooters, the clean, minimalist look of an AR-15 upper without a forward assist is appealing. The absence of the lever contributes to a sleeker profile.
4. Potential for Improved Accuracy (Debatable)
While not universally accepted, some believe removing the forward assist eliminates a potential point of stress or vibration that could negatively affect accuracy. This is a nuanced point and would likely depend on the individual weapon and its use.
Drawbacks of an AR Upper Without Forward Assist
While the benefits are attractive, it's crucial to acknowledge the downsides:
-
Increased Difficulty in Chambering Rounds: The most significant drawback is the increased difficulty in chambering rounds if there's a malfunction. If a round fails to fully seat, you'll have to rely on manual manipulation of the charging handle to resolve the issue, which can be more difficult and time-consuming under stress.
-
Potential for Malfunctions: Without the forward assist, you're more reliant on a perfectly functioning BCG and ammunition. Any issue hindering proper chambering could lead to a stoppage, potentially in a critical situation.
-
Reduced User-Friendliness: For new or less experienced shooters, the lack of a forward assist can make the weapon less forgiving. The reliance on a charging handle alone demands more technical skill and proficiency.
Who Should Consider an AR Upper Without Forward Assist?
An AR-15 upper without a forward assist isn't ideal for everyone. It's generally more suited for experienced shooters who prioritize lightweight builds and are confident in their ability to troubleshoot malfunctions without the aid of the forward assist. These individuals often meticulously maintain their rifles and use high-quality ammunition, minimizing the likelihood of needing the forward assist in the first place.
New or less experienced shooters should generally stick with a standard upper receiver featuring a forward assist. The added safety and ease of use are invaluable for those still developing their skills and knowledge of AR-15 operation.
Conclusion: Informed Choice is Key
The decision of whether or not to choose an AR upper without a forward assist depends entirely on individual needs and experience. Carefully weigh the advantages of reduced weight, streamlined design, and the argument for enhanced reliability against the potential downsides of increased difficulty in resolving malfunctions. This decision should be based on a thorough understanding of your skill level, the intended use of the rifle, and your commitment to maintaining it in optimal condition. Only then can you make an informed choice that's best suited to your situation.