The Glock 19 is a legendary pistol, known for its reliability and ease of use. But even within the Glock 19 family, there are significant differences between generations. This in-depth comparison focuses on the key distinctions between the Glock 19 Gen 1 and Gen 2, helping you decide which might be right for you. Understanding these differences is crucial for any serious Glock enthusiast or prospective buyer. We'll cover everything from the subtle changes in design to their practical implications on the shooting experience.
Key Differences Between Glock 19 Gen 1 and Gen 2
The Glock 19 Gen 1 and Gen 2, while sharing a similar silhouette, feature several key distinctions that affect handling, reliability, and overall performance. These differences might seem minor at first glance, but understanding them is crucial for informed decision-making.
1. The Trigger: A Significant Upgrade
-
Gen 1: The Gen 1 Glock 19 featured a trigger with a noticeably longer and heavier pull. This longer travel distance often resulted in less precision and a less predictable shot break. The trigger's design was also considered less refined compared to later generations, contributing to a less refined shooting experience.
-
Gen 2: Glock addressed these issues with the Gen 2. The trigger pull on the Gen 2 is generally shorter and lighter, resulting in improved accuracy and a more controlled trigger pull. This upgrade significantly enhanced the overall shootability of the pistol. While still characteristically Glock, the trigger felt significantly improved for accuracy and trigger control.
Table 1: Trigger Comparison
| Feature | Gen 1 Glock 19 | Gen 2 Glock 19 |
|---|---|---|
| Trigger Pull | Longer, Heavier | Shorter, Lighter |
| Trigger Feel | Less refined | More refined |
| Accuracy Impact | Negative impact | Positive impact |
2. The Finger Grooves: An Ergonomics Debate
-
Gen 1: The Gen 1 Glock 19 featured prominent finger grooves molded into the grip. While some shooters found these grooves comfortable and conducive to a secure grip, others experienced discomfort or found them restrictive, hindering their natural grip. The positioning of the grooves was a significant point of contention.
-
Gen 2: Glock responded to feedback by removing the finger grooves on the Gen 2. This change allowed for greater adaptability and comfort for a wider range of hand sizes. The absence of finger grooves makes it easier for shooters to customize their grip without the constraints of pre-molded features.
Image: (Insert side-by-side images of Gen 1 and Gen 2 Glock 19 grips, highlighting the presence/absence of finger grooves. Ensure images are compressed for faster loading.)
3. The Frame: Subtle but Important Changes
While not drastically different, there are subtle variations in the frame between the two generations. These changes, often overlooked, can have a measurable impact on feel and performance.
-
Gen 1: The Gen 1 frame generally exhibits a slightly different texture than the Gen 2. The texture might be perceived as less aggressive, though this is subjective and varies based on individual preference and the condition of the specific firearm.
-
Gen 2: The Gen 2 frame often has a more pronounced texturing, enhancing grip and control, especially in wet or sweaty conditions. This difference might seem minimal, but it plays a significant role in overall handling during use.
4. Magazine Release: A Practical Difference
-
Gen 1: The magazine release on the Gen 1 Glock 19 is often perceived as being slightly stiffer or less easily manipulated compared to the Gen 2.
-
Gen 2: The Gen 2 boasts a slightly improved magazine release, making it easier and quicker to change magazines under stress. Though seemingly insignificant, a small upgrade can make a big difference in practical scenarios.
Which Glock 19 Generation Should You Choose?
The choice between a Glock 19 Gen 1 and Gen 2 largely depends on individual preferences and priorities.
-
Gen 1: The Gen 1 is appealing to collectors or those seeking a piece of Glock history. However, its less refined trigger and more divisive finger grooves might deter modern shooters. It's crucial to factor in potential maintenance needs as parts for older generations can be harder to source. Remember to examine the firearm meticulously before purchasing, looking for signs of wear and tear.
-
Gen 2: The Gen 2, with its improved trigger, absence of finger grooves, and enhanced magazine release, makes it a more popular choice for most users. It addresses some of the criticism leveled against the Gen 1 and provides a generally more comfortable and reliable shooting experience. However, keep in mind that used Gen 2 pistols can also show signs of wear and tear so a thorough examination before buying is vital.
Ultimately, handling both generations is the best way to determine personal preference. If possible, visit a range or gun shop offering both models for a hands-on comparison. Consider factors like your hand size, shooting style, and intended use when making your decision. The Gen 2 generally offers improvements in ease of use and ergonomics, while the Gen 1 is a piece of Glock history. The best Glock 19 for you is the one that feels best in your hand and meets your specific needs.