The Striker 12 and the AA-12 are two legendary names in the world of auto-loading shotguns. Both are known for their high-capacity magazines and devastating firepower, but they have key differences that set them apart. This in-depth comparison will explore their features, performance, and suitability for various applications. We'll delve into the nuances of each weapon system to help you understand which is the right choice for your needs, whether you're a firearms enthusiast, a collector, or simply curious about these powerful weapons.
Striker 12: The Civilian Autoloading Shotgun
The Striker 12 is a high-capacity, auto-loading 12-gauge shotgun designed for civilian use. Its unique design and features have made it a popular choice among shooters who need a reliable and powerful shotgun for home defense or other purposes.
Striker 12 Features & Specifications:
- Caliber: 12 gauge
- Action: Auto-loading
- Capacity: 20 rounds (high-capacity magazine)
- Weight: Approximately 8-9 pounds (depending on configuration)
- Barrel Length: Variable, depending on model and legal restrictions
- Notable Features: Reliable operation, high capacity, relatively compact design (for its type), adjustable stock
Striker 12's are known for their reliability. While some early models had issues, modern production versions have largely resolved these problems. The high capacity magazine significantly increases the firepower compared to traditional pump-action or semi-automatic shotguns. Its relatively compact size compared to other auto-loading shotguns makes it more maneuverable in close quarters.
Striker 12 Strengths:
- High Capacity: The 20-round magazine provides significant firepower.
- Reliable Operation: Modern Striker 12s are generally reliable and functional.
- Compact Size: More maneuverable than many comparable autoloading shotguns.
- Customization: Several aftermarket parts are available.
Striker 12 Weaknesses:
- Recoil: The powerful cartridges and rapid firing rate create significant recoil.
- Weight: It's a heavy shotgun, potentially fatiguing during extended use.
- Cost: It's a relatively expensive shotgun.
- Availability: The Striker 12 can be difficult to find, depending on region and legal restrictions.
AA-12: The Military-Grade Auto Shotgun
The AA-12 (Automatic Assault 12) is a fully automatic shotgun developed by Maxwell Atchisson. Originally intended for military and law enforcement applications, its powerful capabilities and unique design have cemented its place in firearms history.
AA-12 Features & Specifications:
- Caliber: 12 gauge
- Action: Fully automatic (select fire capable)
- Capacity: Variable, with high-capacity drum magazines often used.
- Weight: Approximately 10-12 pounds (depending on configuration)
- Barrel Length: Variable, depending on model and legal restrictions.
- Notable Features: Selectable firing modes (auto/semi), high capacity drum magazines, advanced gas operation system.
The AA-12's fully automatic capabilities are its defining feature. This gives it a significant advantage in sustained fire situations. However, this also means significantly increased recoil and ammunition consumption. The drum magazines provide exceptional firepower but add significantly to the weapon's weight and size.
AA-12 Strengths:
- Fully Automatic Fire: Offers sustained firepower unmatched by most shotguns.
- High Capacity Magazines: Allows for a very large number of shots without reloading.
- Robust Design: Built to withstand heavy use and harsh conditions.
AA-12 Weaknesses:
- Excessive Recoil: The fully automatic firing mode generates extreme recoil.
- High Weight: Its considerable weight makes extended use challenging.
- Cost: The AA-12 is exceptionally expensive, often exceeding the price of most other shotguns.
- Legal Restrictions: Strict legal restrictions limit its availability in most jurisdictions.
Striker 12 vs. AA-12: A Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | Striker 12 | AA-12 |
|---|---|---|
| Firing Mode | Semi-automatic | Fully automatic (select fire) |
| Capacity | 20 rounds (magazine) | Variable, up to 20+ (drum) |
| Weight | 8-9 pounds | 10-12 pounds |
| Recoil | High | Extremely High |
| Cost | High | Very High |
| Intended Use | Civilian, Home Defense | Military, Law Enforcement |
| Legality | Varies by jurisdiction | Heavily restricted |
Conclusion: Choosing the Right Autoloading Shotgun
The Striker 12 and the AA-12 represent the pinnacle of auto-loading shotgun technology, each with its strengths and weaknesses. The Striker 12, with its semi-automatic action and high-capacity magazine, is a potent choice for civilian applications demanding significant firepower in a relatively manageable package. The AA-12, on the other hand, is a truly devastating weapon system with its fully automatic capability, but its extreme recoil, weight, cost, and stringent legal restrictions severely limit its accessibility and practical applications for most users. Ultimately, the best choice depends on your specific needs, budget, and legal considerations. Always prioritize safety and responsible firearm ownership.